UKIYO · Journal
Redken All Soft vs Extreme: Dry vs Damaged Hair, and the Kérastase and Sebastian Picks
By Codie Hair, Owner, UKIYO Wānaka
Short answer: Redken All Soft is for dry hair and Redken Extreme is for damaged hair. That split is the right way to think about it. For dry hair we reach for Kérastase Nutritive ($54.60 Bain Satin) or Sebastian Hydre ($50.12). For damaged hair, Kérastase Première ($60.48 Bain) or Sebastian Penetraitt ($50.12). Sebastian is the lower price, Kérastase the premium. Choose by budget.
Updated November 2026. Prices are our live online prices.
Redken All Soft vs Extreme is one of the most common questions we get about Redken, because people buy the wrong one all the time. The choice really comes down to one thing: is your hair dry, or is it damaged? They aren't the same, and they need different care.
Below is how to tell which you have, how All Soft and Extreme compare, and the Kérastase and Sebastian ranges our stylists reach for first for each.
Dry hair vs damaged hair
Dry hair is short on moisture and oil. It feels rough, looks dull and tangles, but the inside of the strand is still intact. The fix is moisture and nourishment.
Damaged hair has a weakened internal structure, usually from bleach, colour, heat or chemical smoothing. It feels weak, stretches when wet, snaps when you brush it and splits at the ends. The fix is repair and strength. Piling more moisture onto badly damaged hair can leave it limp and mushy.
A quick test you can do at home
Take a shed strand, wet it, and gently stretch it. Healthy hair stretches a little and springs back. If it stretches a long way and stays limp, or snaps straight away, it's damaged. If it behaves normally but your hair feels rough and dull overall, it's dry.
Redken All Soft vs Extreme at a glance
Redken All Soft is Redken's moisture range for dry, brittle hair, built around argan oil for softness and shine. Redken Extreme is its strength range for damaged hair, with protein-based care like the Anti-Snap leave-in and the CAT treatment. Both do what they set out to do. Here's how they line up against what we use.
| Your hair | Sebastian (lower price) | Kérastase (premium) | Redken comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry, rough, dull, frizzy but not breaking | Hydre Shampoo $50.12, Hydre Mask $51.88 | Nutritive Bain Satin $54.60, Masquintense $83.16 | All Soft |
| Damaged from colour, bleach or heat | Penetraitt Shampoo $50.12, Penetraitt Mask $51.88 | Première Bain $60.48, Première Masque Filler $91.56 | Extreme or Acidic Bonding |
| Weak, snapping, breaking lengths | No.Breaker Leave-In Cream $63.32 | Résistance Ciment Anti-Usure $70.56 | Extreme Anti-Snap |
Which one should you choose?
If your hair is dry: Kérastase Nutritive or Sebastian Hydre
Kérastase Nutritive Bain Satin $54.60 with Lait Vital $65.52 is the dry-hair pair we sell most. It softens without weighing fine or medium hair down. If your hair is thick and very dry, add Masquintense $83.16 once or twice a week.
Sebastian Hydre Shampoo $50.12 and the Hydre Treatment Mask $51.88 do the same job at a lower price. Hydre feels a little lighter, which suits hair that's dry but fine.
If your hair is damaged: Kérastase Première or Sebastian Penetraitt
Kérastase Première is our first pick for hair that's been lightened, coloured often or heat-styled hard. Kérastase made it for damaged hair, and it starts with Bain Décalcifiant Réparateur $60.48, which also lifts hard-water mineral build-up. Follow with Fondant Fluidité $70.56 each wash and the Masque Filler $91.56 weekly.
Sebastian Penetraitt Rescue Repair Shampoo $50.12 with the Penetraitt Mask $51.88 is the lower-priced route. Sebastian designed it to strengthen and repair chemically treated hair, and it's the one we suggest for blondes on a budget.
If your hair is snapping
Breakage needs a leave-in that stays on the hair. Kérastase Résistance Ciment Anti-Usure $70.56 goes on after washing, with Bain Force Architecte $57.12 as the wash. On the Sebastian side, No.Breaker Leave-In Cream $63.32 is our go-to. Our hair breakage guide covers the causes in more detail.
If your hair is both dry and damaged
Plenty of hair is both, long-time blondes especially. Lead with repair (Première or Penetraitt), then alternate in a moisture mask (Masquintense or Hydre) every second or third wash. Too much protein and hair gets stiff and brittle. Too much moisture and it goes soft and stretchy. Alternating keeps it in balance.
A simple routine for either
- Shampoo two or three times a week, not daily.
- Conditioner every wash, mask once a week.
- Heat protection before every blow-dry or straightener.
- Trim every 8 to 12 weeks so split ends don't travel up the hair.
We still stock some Redken in the salon and online in our Redken collection, so if All Soft or Extreme is working well for you, there's no need to switch.
Why buy from UKIYO
Everything we sell is genuine salon stock, bought from the brands' New Zealand distributors, and it's the same product our stylists use on clients at the basin in Wānaka every day. Free NZ shipping over $75, or pick up from the salon at 28 Helwick St. If you're not sure which one is yours, message us a photo and a stylist will answer.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between Redken All Soft and Extreme?
All Soft is Redken's moisture range for dry, brittle hair. Extreme is its strength range for damaged, breaking hair. Pick All Soft if your hair is dry but strong, and Extreme if it's snapping or over-processed.
Is Redken All Soft good for damaged hair?
All Soft is made for dry hair. It will soften damaged hair but won't repair it. For damage we'd use Kérastase Première or Sebastian Penetraitt.
What's the Kérastase equivalent of Redken All Soft?
Kérastase Nutritive. Bain Satin ($54.60) with Lait Vital is the closest match for dry hair, and Masquintense adds a deeper treatment.
What's the Kérastase equivalent of Redken Extreme?
Kérastase Première for damaged, processed hair, or Kérastase Résistance if the main problem is breakage and weak lengths.
Is there a cheaper alternative to Kérastase for dry or damaged hair?
Yes. Sebastian Hydre for dry hair and Sebastian Penetraitt for damaged hair, both from $50.12 for the shampoo.
How do I know if my hair is dry or damaged?
Wet a shed strand and gently stretch it. If it springs back, your hair is healthy and probably just dry. If it stretches a long way and stays limp, or snaps, it's damaged.
Can I use moisture and repair products together?
Yes, and dry, damaged hair usually needs both. Use the repair range as your base and swap in a moisture mask every second or third wash.
Keep reading
Read more

Short answer: You can buy Redken in NZ from salons, including UKIYO. We stock genuine salon Redken in our Wānaka salon and online, though our range is smaller than it was and some lines are down t...

Short answer: No, tape-in extensions don't damage healthy hair when they're fitted, moved up and removed properly. The damage people see comes from too much weight on fine hair, tapes left in long ...

































